[1]Skip to content
[3] DEV Community
[4][                    ]
[6]
[7] Log in [8] Create account

DEV Community

● Add reaction
[sp] Like [mu] Unicorn [ex] Exploding Head [ra] Raised Hands [fi] Fire
Jump to Comments Save
Copy link
Copied to Clipboard
[20] Share to Twitter [21] Share to LinkedIn [22] Share to Reddit [23] Share to
Hacker News [24] Share to Facebook [25] Share to Mastodon
[26]Share Post via... [27]Report Abuse
[28] Cover image for Decorating Ruby - Part Two - Method Added Decoration
[29]Brandon Weaver
[30]Brandon Weaver

Posted on Aug 18, 2019 • Updated on Jan 21, 2021

●   ●   ●   ●   ●  

Decorating Ruby - Part Two - Method Added Decoration

[31]#ruby

[32]Decorating Ruby (3 Part Series)

[33] 1 Decorating Ruby - Part One - Symbol Method Decoration [34] 2 Decorating
Ruby - Part Two - Method Added Decoration [35] 3 Decorating Ruby - Part Three -
Prepending Decoration

One precursor of me writing an article is if I keep forgetting how something's
done, causing me to write a reference to look back on for later. This is one
such article.

[36] What's in Store for Today?

We'll be looking at the next type of decoration, which involves intercepting
method_added to make a more fluent interface.

[37]The "Dark Lord" Crimson with Metaprogramming magic

Table of Contents

  • [38]Part One - Symbol Method Decoration
  • [39]Part Two - Method Added Decoration
  • [40]Part Three - Prepending Decoration

[41]<< Previous | [42]Next >>

[43] What Does Method Added Decoration Look Like?

You've seen the Symbol Method variant:

private def something; end

Readers that were paying very close attention in the last article may have
noticed when I said that I preferred that style of declaring private methods in
Ruby, but this was after the way that can be debatably considered more popular
and widely used in the community:

private

def something; end
def something_else; end

Using private like this means that every method defined after will be
considered private. We know how the first one works, but what about the second?
There's no way it's using method names because it catches both of those methods
and doesn't change the definition syntax.

That's what we'll be looking into and learning today, and let me tell you it's
a metaprogramming trip.

[44] Making Our Own Method Added Decoration

As with the last article we're going to need to learn about a few tools before
we'll be ready to implement this one.

[45] Module Inclusion

Ruby uses Module inclusion as a way to extend classes with additional behavior,
sometimes requiring an interface to be met before it can do so. Enumerable is
one of the most common, and requires an each implementation to work:

class Collection
  include Enumerable

  def initialize(*items)
    @items = items
  end

  def each(&fn)
    return @items.to_enum unless block_given?
    @items.each { |item| fn.call(item) }
  end
end

(yield could be used here instead, but is less explicit and can be confusing to
teach.)

By defining that one method we've given our class the ability to do all types
of amazing things like map, select, and more.

Through those few lines we've added a lot of functionality to a class. Here's
the interesting part about Ruby: it also provides hooks to let Enumerable know
it was included, including what included it.

[46] Feeling Included

Let's say we have our own module, [47]Affable, which gives us a method to say
"hi":

module Affable
  def greeting
    "It's so very lovely to see you today!"
  end
end

My, it is quite an [48]Affable module, now isn't it?

We could even go as far as to make a particularly Affable lemur:

class Lemur
  include Affable
  def initialize(name) @name = name; end
end

Lemur.new("Indigo").greeting
=> "It's so very lovely to see you today!"

What a classy lemur, yes.

[49] Hook, Line, and Sinker

Let's say that we wanted to tell what particular animal was Affable. We can use
included to see just that:

module Affable
  def self.included(klass)
    puts "#{klass.name} has become extra Affable!"
  end
end

If we were to re-include that module:

class Lemur
  include Affable
  def initialize(name) @name = name; end
end

# STDOUT: Lemur has become extra Affable!
# => :initialize

Right classy. Oh, right, speaking of classy...

[50] Extra Classy Indeed

So we can hook inclusion of a module, great! Why do we care?

What if we wanted to both include methods into a class as well as extend its
behavior?

With just include it will apply all the behavior to instances of a class. With
just extend it will apply all the behavior to the class itself. We can't do
both.

...ok ok, it's Ruby, you caught me, we can totally do both.

As it turns out, include and extend are just methods on a class. We could just
Lemur.extend(ExtraBehavior) if we wanted to, or we could use our fun little
hooks from earlier.

A common convention for using this technique is a sub-module called
ClassMethods, like so:

module Affable
  def self.included(klass)
    klass.extend(ClassMethods)
  end

  module ClassMethods
    def affable?
      true
    end
  end
end

This allows us to inject behavior directly into the class as well as other
behavior we want to include in instances.

Part of me thinks this is so I don't have to remember the difference between
include and extend, but I always remember that and don't have to spend 20
minutes flipping between the two and prepend to see which one actually works,
absolutely not.

Now remember the title about Method Added being the technique for today? Oh
yes, there's a hook for that as well, but first we need to indicate that
something needs to be hooked in the first place.

[51] Raise Your Flag

We can intercept a method being added, but how do we know which method should
be intercepted? We'd need to add a flag to let that hook know it's time to
start intercepting in full force.

module Affable
  def self.included(klass)
    klass.extend(ClassMethods)
  end

  module ClassMethods
    def extra_affable
      @extra_affable = true
    end
  end
end

If you remember private, this could be the flag to indicate that every method
afterwards should be private:

private

def something; end
def something_else; end

Same idea here, and once a flag is raised it can also be taken down to make
sure later methods aren't impacted as well. We keep hinting at hooking method
added, so let's go ahead and do just that.

[52] Method Added

Now that we have our flag, we have enough to hook into method_added:

module Affable
  def self.included(klass)
    klass.extend(ClassMethods)
  end

  module ClassMethods
    def extra_affable
      @extra_affable = true
    end

    def method_added(method_name)
      return unless @extra_affable

      @extra_affable = false
      # ...
    end
  end
end

We can use our flag to ignore method_added unless said flag is set. After we
check that, we can take down the flag to make sure additional methods defined
after aren't affected as well. For private this doesn't happen, but we want to
be polite. It is and Affable module after all.

[53] Politely Aliasing

Speaking of politeness, it's not precisely kind to just overwrite a method
without giving a way to call it as it was. We can use alias_method to get a new
name to the method before we overwrite it:

def method_added(method_name)
  return unless @extra_affable

  @extra_affable = false

  original_method_name = "#{method_name}_without_affability".to_sym
  alias_method original_method_name, method_name
end

This means that we can access the original method through this name.

[54] Wrap Battle

So we have the original method aliased, our hook in place, let's get to
overwriting that method then! As with the last tutorial we can use
define_method to do this:

module Affable
  def self.included(klass)
    klass.extend(ClassMethods)
  end

  module ClassMethods
    def extra_affable
      @extra_affable = true
    end

    def method_added(method_name)
      return unless @extra_affable

      @extra_affable = false

      original_method_name = "#{method_name}_without_affability".to_sym
      alias_method original_method_name, method_name

      define_method(method_name) do |*args, &fn|
        original_result = send(original_method_name, *args, &fn)

        "#{original_result} Very lovely indeed!"
      end
    end
  end
end

Overwriting our original class again:

class Lemur
  include Affable

  def initialize(name) @name = name; end

  extra_affable

  def farewell
    "Farewell! It was lovely to chat."
  end
end

We can give it a try:

Lemur.new("Indigo").farewell
=> "Farewell! It was lovely to chat. Very lovely indeed!"

[55] send Help!

Wait wait wait wait, send? Didn't we use method last time?

We did, but remember that method_added is a class method that does not have the
context of an instance of the class, or in other words it has no idea where the
farewell method is located.

send lets us treat this as an instance again by sending the method name
directly. Now we could use method inside of here as well, but that can be a bit
more expensive.

Only the contents inside define_method's block are executed in the context of
the instance.

[56] executive Functions

If we wanted to, we could have our special method take blocks which execute in
the context of an instance as well, and this is an extra special bonus trick
for this post.

Say that we made extra_affable also take a block that allows us to manipulate
the original value and still execute in the context of the instance:

class Lemur
  include Affable

  def initialize(name) @name = name; end

  extra_affable { |original|
    "#{@name}: #{original} Very lovely indeed!"
  }

  def farewell
    "Farewell! It was lovely to chat."
  end
end

With normal blocks, this will evaluate in the context of the class, but we want
it to evaluate in the context of the instance instead. That's what we have
instance_exec for:

module Affable
  def self.included(klass)
    klass.extend(ClassMethods)
  end

  module ClassMethods
    def extra_affable(&fn)
      @extra_affable    = true
      @extra_affable_fn = fn
    end

    def method_added(method_name)
      return unless @extra_affable

      @extra_affable   = false
      extra_affable_fn = @extra_affable_fn

      original_method_name = "#{method_name}_without_affability".to_sym
      alias_method original_method_name, method_name

      define_method(method_name) do |*args, &fn|
        original_result = send(original_method_name, *args, &fn)
        instance_exec(original_result, &extra_affable_fn)
      end
    end
  end
end

Running that gives us this:

Lemur.new("Indigo").farewell
# => "Indigo: Farewell! It was lovely to chat. Very lovely indeed!"

Now pay very close attention to this line:

extra_affable_fn = @extra_affable_fn

We need to use this because inside define_method's block is inside the
instance, which has no clue what @extra_affable_fn is. That said, it can still
see outside to the context where the block was called, meaning it can see that
local version of extra_affable_fn sitting right there, allowing us to call it:

instance_exec(original_result, &extra_affable_fn)

[57] instance_eval vs instance_exec?

Why not use instance_eval? instance_exec allows us to pass along arguments as
well, otherwise instance_eval would make a lot of sense to evaluate something
in an instance. Instead, we need to execute something in the context of an
instance, so we use instance_exec here.

[58] Wrapping Up

So that was quite a lot of magic, and it took me a fair bit to really
understand what some of it was doing and why. That's perfectly ok, if I
understood everything the first time I'd be worried because that means I'm not
really learning anything!

One issue I think this will have later is I wonder how poorly having multiple
hooks to method_added will work. If it turns out it makes things go boom in a
spectacularly pretty and confounding way there'll be a part three. If not, this
paragraph will disappear and I'll pretend to not know what you're talking about
if you ask me about it.

There's a lot of potential here for some really interesting things, but there's
also a lot of potential for abuse. Be sure to not abuse such magic, because for
every layer of redefinition code can become increasingly harder to reason about
and test later.

In most cases I would instead advocate for SimpleDelegate, Forwardable, or
simple inheritance with super to extend behavior of classes. Don't use a
chainsaw where hedge trimmers will do, but on occasion it's nice to know a
chainsaw is there for those particularly gnarly problems.

Discretion is the name of the game.

Table of Contents

  • [59]Part One - Symbol Method Decoration
  • [60]Part Two - Method Added Decoration
  • [61]Part Three - Prepending Decoration

[62]<< Previous | [63]Next >>

[64]Decorating Ruby (3 Part Series)

[65] 1 Decorating Ruby - Part One - Symbol Method Decoration [66] 2 Decorating
Ruby - Part Two - Method Added Decoration [67] 3 Decorating Ruby - Part Three -
Prepending Decoration

Top comments (2)

Subscribe
pic
[                    ]
Personal Trusted User
[75] Create template

Templates let you quickly answer FAQs or store snippets for re-use.

Submit Preview [78]Dismiss
 
[79] edisonywh profile image
[80] Edison Yap
Edison Yap
[82] [https] Edison Yap
Follow
An aspiring software engineer from the tiny city of Kuala Lumpur.

  • Location
    Stockholm, Sweden
  • Education
    RMIT University, Melbourne
  • Work
    Software Engineer at Klarna
  • Joined
    Jul 25, 2018

• [84] Aug 18 '19 • Edited on Aug 18 • Edited

  • [86]Copy link
  • 
  • Hide
  • 
  • 
  • 

Wow this is really cool, thanks for sharing Brandon!

Is there a way to hook onto the last method_added? For example I'd like to
execute something after all methods are added

EDIT: also quick search online seems to say that method_added only works for
instance methods, but there's singleton_method_added hook for class methods
too!

1 like Like [89] Reply
 
[90] baweaver profile image
[91] Brandon Weaver
Brandon Weaver
[93] [https] Brandon Weaver
Follow
Principal Ruby Engineer at Gusto on Payroll Services. Autistic / ADHD, He /
Him. I'm the Lemur guy.

  • Location
    San Francisco, CA
  • Work
    Principal Engineer - Payroll Services at Gusto
  • Joined
    Jan 16, 2019

• [95] Aug 18 '19 • Edited on Aug 18 • Edited

  • [97]Copy link
  • 
  • Hide
  • 
  • 
  • 

Technically in Ruby there's never a point in which methods are no longer added,
so it's a bit hard to hook that. One potential is to use TracePoint to hook the
ending of a class definition and retaining a class of "infected" classes, but
that'd be slow.

Look for "Class End Event" in this article: [99]medium.com/@baweaver/
exploring-tra...

EDIT - ...though now I'm curious if one could use such things to freeze a class
from modifications.

1 like Like [101] Reply
[102]Code of Conduct • [103]Report abuse

Are you sure you want to hide this comment? It will become hidden in your post,
but will still be visible via the comment's [107]permalink.

[109][ ]

Hide child comments as well

Confirm

For further actions, you may consider blocking this person and/or [111]
reporting abuse

Read next

[112]
cherryramatis profile image

Bringing more sweetness to Ruby with Sorbet types 🍦

Cherry Ramatis - Sep 18 '23

[113]
hungle00 profile image

Ruby's main object

hungle00 - Oct 1 '23

[114]
braindeaf profile image

Making a YouTube Short

RobL - Sep 28 '23

[115]
iberianpig profile image

Enhance Your Touchpad Experience on Linux with ThumbSense!

Kohei Yamada - Sep 27 '23

[116] [https] Brandon Weaver
Follow
Principal Ruby Engineer at Gusto on Payroll Services. Autistic / ADHD, He /
Him. I'm the Lemur guy.

  • Location
    San Francisco, CA
  • Work
    Principal Engineer - Payroll Services at Gusto
  • Joined
    Jan 16, 2019

More from [118]Brandon Weaver

[119] Understanding Ruby - Memoization
#ruby #beginners
[120] In Favor of Ruby Central Memberships
#ruby #community
[121] Pattern Matching Interfaces in Ruby
#ruby #rails #functional

Once suspended, baweaver will not be able to comment or publish posts until
their suspension is removed.

      [                                                                      ]
      [                                                                      ]
      [                                                                      ]
Note: [                                                                      ]

Submit & Suspend

Once unsuspended, baweaver will be able to comment and publish posts again.

      [                                                                      ]
      [                                                                      ]
      [                                                                      ]
Note: [                                                                      ]

Submit & Unsuspend

Once unpublished, all posts by baweaver will become hidden and only accessible
to themselves.

If baweaver is not suspended, they can still re-publish their posts from their
dashboard.

Note:[                    ]

Unpublish all posts

Once unpublished, this post will become invisible to the public and only
accessible to Brandon Weaver.

They can still re-publish the post if they are not suspended.

Unpublish Post

Thanks for keeping DEV Community safe. Here is what you can do to flag
baweaver:

[129]( ) Make all posts by baweaver less visible

baweaver consistently posts content that violates DEV Community's code of
conduct because it is harassing, offensive or spammy.

[130] Report other inappropriate conduct

Confirm Flag

Unflagging baweaver will restore default visibility to their posts.

Confirm Unflag

[133]DEV Community — A constructive and inclusive social network for software
developers. With you every step of your journey.

  • [134] Home
  • [135] Podcasts
  • [136] Videos
  • [137] Tags
  • [138] FAQ
  • [139] Forem Shop
  • [140] Advertise on DEV
  • [141] About
  • [142] Contact
  • [143] Guides
  • [144] Software comparisons

  • [145] Code of Conduct
  • [146] Privacy Policy
  • [147] Terms of use

Built on [148]Forem — the [149]open source software that powers [150]DEV and
other inclusive communities.

Made with love and [151]Ruby on Rails. DEV Community © 2016 - 2024.

DEV Community

We're a place where coders share, stay up-to-date and grow their careers.

[152] Log in [153] Create account
● ● ● ● ●

References:

[1] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#main-content
[3] https://dev.to/
[6] https://dev.to/search
[7] https://dev.to/enter
[8] https://dev.to/enter?state=new-user
[20] https://twitter.com/intent/tweet?text=%22Decorating%20Ruby%20-%20Part%20Two%20-%20Method%20Added%20Decoration%22%20by%20%40keystonelemur%20%23DEVCommunity%20https%3A%2F%2Fdev.to%2Fbaweaver%2Fdecorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj
[21] https://www.linkedin.com/shareArticle?mini=true&url=https%3A%2F%2Fdev.to%2Fbaweaver%2Fdecorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj&title=Decorating%20Ruby%20-%20Part%20Two%20-%20Method%20Added%20Decoration&summary=How%20various%20forms%20of%20method%20decoration%20work%20in%20Ruby&source=DEV%20Community
[22] https://www.reddit.com/submit?url=https%3A%2F%2Fdev.to%2Fbaweaver%2Fdecorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj&title=Decorating%20Ruby%20-%20Part%20Two%20-%20Method%20Added%20Decoration
[23] https://news.ycombinator.com/submitlink?u=https%3A%2F%2Fdev.to%2Fbaweaver%2Fdecorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj&t=Decorating%20Ruby%20-%20Part%20Two%20-%20Method%20Added%20Decoration
[24] https://www.facebook.com/sharer.php?u=https%3A%2F%2Fdev.to%2Fbaweaver%2Fdecorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj
[25] https://toot.kytta.dev/?text=https%3A%2F%2Fdev.to%2Fbaweaver%2Fdecorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj
[26] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#
[27] https://dev.to/report-abuse
[28] https://res.cloudinary.com/practicaldev/image/fetch/s--UjPHgJnM--/c_imagga_scale,f_auto,fl_progressive,h_420,q_auto,w_1000/https://thepracticaldev.s3.amazonaws.com/i/rdvh6fph3zoga5f9pw98.png
[29] https://dev.to/baweaver
[30] https://dev.to/baweaver
[31] https://dev.to/t/ruby
[32] https://dev.to/baweaver/series/10894
[33] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-1-symbol-method-decoration-4po2
[34] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj
[35] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-three-prepending-decoration-1ehc
[36] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#whats-in-store-for-today
[37] https://res.cloudinary.com/practicaldev/image/fetch/s--L5_TPTzS--/c_limit%2Cf_auto%2Cfl_progressive%2Cq_auto%2Cw_800/https://thepracticaldev.s3.amazonaws.com/i/5pzy2brl5apjtt4edgrm.png
[38] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-1-symbol-method-decoration-4po2
[39] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj
[40] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-three-prepending-decoration-1ehc
[41] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-1-symbol-method-decoration-4po2
[42] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-three-prepending-decoration-1ehc
[43] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#what-does-method-added-decoration-look-like
[44] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#making-our-own-method-added-decoration
[45] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#module-inclusion
[46] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#feeling-included
[47] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/affable
[48] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/affable
[49] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#hook-line-and-sinker
[50] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#extra-classy-indeed
[51] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#raise-your-flag
[52] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#method-added
[53] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#politely-aliasing
[54] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#wrap-battle
[55] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#-raw-send-endraw-help
[56] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#-raw-exec-endraw-utive-functions
[57] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#-raw-instanceeval-endraw-vs-raw-instanceexec-endraw-
[58] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#wrapping-up
[59] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-1-symbol-method-decoration-4po2
[60] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj
[61] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-three-prepending-decoration-1ehc
[62] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-1-symbol-method-decoration-4po2
[63] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-three-prepending-decoration-1ehc
[64] https://dev.to/baweaver/series/10894
[65] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-1-symbol-method-decoration-4po2
[66] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj
[67] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-three-prepending-decoration-1ehc
[75] https://dev.to/settings/response-templates
[78] https://dev.to/404.html
[79] https://dev.to/edisonywh
[80] https://dev.to/edisonywh
[82] https://dev.to/edisonywh
[84] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#comment-e96o
[86] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#comment-e96o
[89] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj/comments/new/e96o
[90] https://dev.to/baweaver
[91] https://dev.to/baweaver
[93] https://dev.to/baweaver
[95] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#comment-e9g0
[97] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#comment-e9g0
[99] https://medium.com/@baweaver/exploring-tracepoint-in-ruby-part-two-events-f4fd291992f5
[101] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj/comments/new/e9g0
[102] https://dev.to/code-of-conduct
[103] https://dev.to/report-abuse
[107] https://dev.to/baweaver/decorating-ruby-part-two-method-added-decoration-48mj#
[111] https://dev.to/report-abuse
[112] https://dev.to/cherryramatis/bringing-more-sweetness-to-ruby-with-sorbet-types-13jp
[113] https://dev.to/hungle00/rubys-main-object-5hni
[114] https://dev.to/braindeaf/making-a-youtube-short-5gih
[115] https://dev.to/iberianpig/enhance-your-touchpad-experience-on-linux-with-thumbsense-391n
[116] https://dev.to/baweaver
[118] https://dev.to/baweaver
[119] https://dev.to/baweaver/understanding-ruby-memoization-2be5
[120] https://dev.to/baweaver/in-favor-of-ruby-central-memberships-15gl
[121] https://dev.to/baweaver/pattern-matching-interfaces-in-ruby-1b15
[130] javascript:void(0);
[133] https://dev.to/
[134] https://dev.to/
[135] https://dev.to/pod
[136] https://dev.to/videos
[137] https://dev.to/tags
[138] https://dev.to/faq
[139] https://shop.forem.com/
[140] https://dev.to/advertise
[141] https://dev.to/about
[142] https://dev.to/contact
[143] https://dev.to/guides
[144] https://dev.to/software-comparisons
[145] https://dev.to/code-of-conduct
[146] https://dev.to/privacy
[147] https://dev.to/terms
[148] https://www.forem.com/
[149] https://dev.to/t/opensource
[150] https://dev.to/
[151] https://dev.to/t/rails
[152] https://dev.to/enter
[153] https://dev.to/enter?state=new-user